Matthew, the ‘wee marvel’: The first gene therapy ALD recipient

Matthew, who was born with ALD, poses with his two brothers in a field
The Elliott brothers Christmas 2020, from left Alex, Matthew and Lee

When the Elliott brothers are asked how many siblings they have, they always say, “four.” It’s a way of honoring the memory of their eldest brother, Marc, who died more than 10 years ago of adrenoleukodystrophy (ALD).

ALD is a degenerative condition that destroys the protective sheath surrounding the brain’s neurons. Gradually, as the disease progresses, symptoms grow worse, including blindness, deafness, and loss of muscle control. Without effective treatment, the disease is fatal.

The two youngest, Lee, 7, and Alex, 4, never met Marc, but still, they miss him. Older brother, Matthew, was just a baby when Marc died, yet the connection runs deep, beyond brotherhood. It’s a story that even now, as he approaches his 12th birthday, Matthew is not ready to hear.

It began in a hospital waiting room in Enniskillen, a town in Northern Ireland, 80 miles west of Belfast, a short walk from Adel and Damien Elliott’s home. Their 4-year-old, Marc, had been ill on- and off-again with a vomiting bug since he was a toddler. On this day, they were summoned to the hospital for genetic testing. “I just knew something bad was coming,” says Adel.

Marc, who had ALD, sits on a bed smiling.
Marc, shortly after his ALD diagnosis

Like many rare diseases, families often suffer through a very long and frustrating diagnostic odyssey and at the end get devastating news about their child’s condition and prognosis. In this case, the Elliotts came to understand that Marc’s disease would lead to his death. Adel recalls,  “I asked, ‘Is this going to kill him?’ The nurse looked at me and said, ‘I’m so sorry.’”

The Elliotts traveled to Belfast and then Bristol, England, for more testing. An MRI showed lesions (damage) on Marc’s brain, confirming the ALD diagnosis. But that wasn’t all. ALD, they would learn, is a genetic disorder, carried by women and passed to their children, mostly affecting boys. Their 2-week-old son, Matthew, would need to be tested too.

Just three days after his christening, Matthew was found to have the same gene mutation as his big brother. “When your heart has been broken to pieces, you don’t expect it could possibly break anymore,” Adel says.

Marc, who was born with ALD, holds his baby brother, Matthew, in a blanket.
Christening day: Marc holding baby Matthew

With limited treatment options for ALD, doctors recommended a bone marrow transplant for Marc, using healthy blood stem cells from a donor to replace his diseased bone marrow. Although they were able to find a suitable donor, his body rejected the transplant. He began slowly slipping away. He lost his peripheral vision and most of his mobility, “but he never lost his smile,” Adel says. On Aug. 14, 2010, the 6-year-old died in his parent’s arms.

It turns out the heart can break to pieces — again and again.

To focus on Matthew’s survival, the Elliotts buried their grief. “We could not rest,” Adel says. They would travel to Belfast for regular checkups and routine MRIs, and hold their breath as they listened to the doctors say, “unchanged.” They would start Matthew on a concoction of cooking oils — made famous in the 1992 film “Lorenzo’s oil” — aimed at reducing the very-long-chain fatty acids that accumulate in ALD. And all the while, they began to think about expanding their family. Would it be possible? By conceiving through in vitro fertilization, it would. They could have the embryos tested to make sure their children didn’t carry the disease.

Experimental gene therapy

Meanwhile, an international team of researchers, led by Dr. David Williams — chief scientific officer and chief of Hematology/Oncology at Boston Children’s Hospital — had developed a study protocol aimed at halting the progression of ALD using ex-vivo lentiviral gene therapy. Instead of taking cells from a donor, bone marrow would be taken from the boys themselves, treated with a virus carrying the gene for the ALD protein, then reinfused.

Graph that explains how ex-vivo gene therapy works.

“There are two great advantages to gene therapy,” Dr. Williams says. “First, patients don’t have to wait to find a donor match. Second, because we use their own, gene-modified stem cells, there’s no risk of graft-versus-host-disease, and the patients do not require any immunosuppression drugs, which can have very significant, even fatal, side effects.”

The Elliotts traveled to Great Ormond Street Hospital in London, a long-time collaborator of Boston Children’s, to learn more about the experimental treatment. Further testing would be needed, but Matthew appeared to be a strong candidate as long as he didn’t have a sibling who was a bone-marrow match, which would eliminate him from the study. The London clinical trial wasn’t up and running yet, but the one in Boston would be open that summer.

“This was all predetermined — just in case,” says Adel. “We had no idea if gene therapy would actually work. It was a huge risk.”

Matthew, who was born with ALD, poses with his parents
Damien, Adel and 2-year-old Matthew

Hope amidst heartache

The day following Matthew’s 4th birthday, on April 25, 2013, Adel had an appointment with her midwife. She was nine months pregnant with her third son, Lee. The phone rang. There were changes in Matthew’s MRI. “It was like déjà vu, because I was nine months pregnant with Matthew when Marc took sick,” she says.

Unless Matthew had a 10 out of 10 bone-marrow match, the Elliotts weren’t willing to travel that route again. At only nine days old, their son, Lee, was tested to see if he would be a suitable donor. While Adel waited in the maternity unit for the test results, her mom, who recently had been diagnosed with glioblastoma, was having brain surgery in another wing of the same hospital.

Lee was not a match after all: a moment of relief. Matthew had passed the first hurdle to become a candidate for the clinical trial. Within days, the Elliotts were on a call with Colleen Dansereau, director of Clinical Operations for the Boston Children’s Gene Therapy Program. “She told us, ‘See you this weekend,” Adel recalls.

Four weeks and numerous tests and doctor appointments later, Colleen called to deliver the news. “Matthew is eligible for the trial! He will be our first patient.”

Elated, the Elliotts returned home for two weeks, and then headed back to Boston for six months. Matthew’s blood stem cells were collected and in a highly-specialized laboratory, a viral vector was used to insert a correct version of the faulty gene. Then, he received chemotherapy to make room for the genetically-altered stem cells.

Finally, on Oct. 25, 2013, Matthew received the gene therapy treatment: a single infusion that everyone hoped would prevent ALD from affecting his brain. “I messaged home, this is the start of Matthew’s new life,” Adel says. “And my family started Facetiming me. I thought it was because of this exciting news. It wasn’t. My mom had died at the exact same moment Matthew was given life.”

Matthew, in Boston for gene therapy with his family in 2013
Christmas in Boston, 2013: From left, Matthew, Damien, Lee and Adel

Matthew’s future

Seven years have passed. Matthew continues to show no sign of disease activity. “He sailed through gene therapy,” says Adel. “He was a wee marvel.”

Every July, the family celebrates Marc’s birthday. “He’s very much a part of our lives,” Adel says. This year, there will be 17 candles on his cake.

Only recently, prompted by questions from his brother, Lee — “Why does Matthew have to take medicine? Why is he going to the doctors?” — Matthew also began asking questions. “Is this not normal? Doesn’t everybody do this?”

“No,” said Adel. “They don’t.”

Matthew paused for a few moments, “I don’t want to die.”

Adel reassured him, “You’re not going to die.”

“But Marc died,” he said.

It was the first time Matthew had ever made the connection he had the same illness as Marc.

That same week, when the Elliotts returned to Great Ormond Street Hospital for one of their many follow-up appointments, Adel encouraged Matthew to ask the doctors any questions he might have.

“When will I be cured?” he asked.

Adel still remembers how they looked at Matthew, empathetically, and what they said to him, “We honestly can’t answer that, but as long as you’re here, we’re here. We’re learning from you every day, so keep living your life the way you are.”

Learn more about Gene Therapy for ALD.

Share this: